Paul DeMuro

Trial Attorney for “Bet the Company” Litigation, Civil Rights, Securities, Select Criminal Cases and High-Stakes Disputes.

Biography

Paul DeMuro has devoted more than 30 years of practice exclusively to litigation and trial work. He represents plaintiffs and defendants in complex disputes involving significant financial exposure, operational risk, reputational concerns, civil rights and regulatory scrutiny.

Paul has tried cases and argued appeals in state and federal trial and appellate courts across the country in both civil and criminal matters. He also regularly represents clients before FINRA arbitration panels, major private arbitration tribunals throughout the United States, and the London Court of International Arbitration. He is a Fellow of the American College of Trial Lawyers.

Clients rely on Paul when disputes become business-critical or personally consequential. His practice includes complex commercial litigation, oil and gas disputes, securities matters, construction litigation, intellectual property and trade secret litigation, employment and civil rights cases, class actions, catastrophic personal injury claims, and selected criminal defense matters.

Paul joined Frederic Dorwart, Lawyers PLLC in 1996 after practicing in New Mexico for three years. Since 2003, he has served on the Criminal Justice Act Panel for the United States District Court for the Northern District of Oklahoma, representing indigent defendants in federal criminal cases. Since 2010, he has also served as an Adjunct Settlement Judge for the Northern District of Oklahoma as part of the court’s mandatory settlement conference program.

Paul graduated second in his class from the University of New Mexico School of Law, where he served as Notes Editor for the UNM Law Review, was elected to the Order of the Coif, and received the Julia Raymond McCulloch Constitutional Law Award. He earned his undergraduate degree from Princeton University, where he played varsity football.

Representative Recent Engagements

  • Appointed lead Class Counsel, and obtained final approval of a landmark class action consent decree in federal civil rights lawsuit seeking to reform Oklahoma’s competency restoration system. Awaiting final approval by Oklahoma’s legislature.
  • In federal civil rights case, obtained multi-million dollar settlement against private prison company, and medical providers, arising from in-custody death of person suffering serious medical issues.
  • Obtained seven figure verdict, and defeated $60 million counterclaim, after two-week jury trial in Maryland state court, on behalf of Tulsa-based specialty contractor against international construction company in contract case arising from construction of a power plant. Litigation costs and pre-judgement interest awarded.
  • Successfully defended doctor accused of federal kick-back violations and conspiracy, obtaining dismissal of 30-count indictment.
  • Obtained seven-figure judgment, following bench trial, in derivative shareholder suit by minority shareholder for directors’ breach of fiduciary duty.
  • Obtained multi-million dollar verdict, after state court jury trial, in favor of independent oil and gas producer against operator for grossly negligent drilling operations.
  • Obtained defense verdict, after two week federal jury trial, for public traded energy company in minority shareholder suit involving a cash out merger. Plaintiffs sought $48 million, jury awarded zero. Court awarded client seven-figure attorney fee award.
  • Obtained substantial plaintiff’s verdict in wrongful arrest case against municipality after state court jury trial, with jury awarding 100% of requested damages
  • Successfully defended regional broker-dealer firm against unsuitability and fraud claims by a municipal government in FINRA arbitration proceeding. After two week hearing, claimant’s $5 million claims denied and attorney fees awarded in favor of broker-dealer.
  • Obtained multi-million dollar judgment for oil and gas producer following a four week jury trial in gas purchase contract dispute in Oklahoma state court. Fees awarded to client. Obtained multi-million dollar settlement in related case after the verdict.
  • Obtained substantial plaintiff’s jury verdict in federal premises liability case against national retailer, after 10th Circuit revered and ordered second trial, with jury awarding 150% of requested damages.
  • Co-lead counsel in federal civil rights class action case against Oklahoma’s Department of Human Services, achieving landmark reform of Oklahoma’s child welfare agency. Court awarded seven-figure attorney fee award.
  • Secured client’s release from prison, and vacated convictions, for wrongfully convicted citizen arising from police corruption scandal in Tulsa, Oklahoma.
  • Successfully defended numerous targets before Oklahoma’s Multicounty Grand Jury, avoiding charges.
  • Represented accused citizens in jury trials and federal sentencing for variety of alleged crimes, including murder, felony assault, tax evasion, weapons charges, fraud, drug cases and others.
  • Obtained court-ordered injunctive relief in several broker transition cases, leading to favorable settlements.
  • Obtained seven-figure award from FINRA arbitration panel on behalf of regional retail brokerage firm, including punitive damages, against Wall Street brokerage firm for unfair competition and broker recruitment.
  • Obtained multi-million dollar settlement for senior-living community developer, following five week jury trial in San Diego, California, involving water-infiltration in high-rise residential building.
  • Obtained multi-million dollar settlement for developer against general contractor, subcontractors and professionals for multiple construction defects in residential retirement community in Orange County, California.
  • Co-lead counsel in action obtaining multi-million dollar settlement for software developer in trademark and copyright infringement action in federal court against national flight simulation firm.
  • Obtained substantial judgment, following state jury trial, in trade secrets action between competing regional petrochemical lubricant distributors. Fees awarded to client.
  • In bad faith insurance case, obtained multi-million dollar settlement for oil and gas producer against insurer that refused to cover losses arising from a sub-surface blow out of gas well in Cameron Parish, Louisiana.
  • Obtained multi-million judgment for internet-based affinity banking company for breach of development contract following arbitration hearing and award against national Washington, D.C.-based lobbying group.
  • Achieved settlement against Oklahoma DHS in “Precious Doe” case resulting in Oklahoma’s Department of Corrections and DHS adopting new policies for placement of babies born to incarcerated mothers.
  • Obtained injunctive order freezing assets of executive director of non-profit foundation accused of embezzling foundation funds. Led to seven-figure summary judgment on behalf of foundation.
  • Obtained multi-million dollar settlement for grievously injured electrical burn victim against utility company.
  • Obtained substantial settlement for female financial advisor for alleged gender discrimination against a Wall Street financial services firm, after defeating summary judgment, with Court finding evidence of gender-based disparate treatment in firm’s reaction to financial advisor’s trading patterns.

• Oil and Gas
• Energy
• Banking and Financial Services
• Construction and Infrastructure
• Healthcare and Corrections
• Securities and Brokerage Firms
• Technology and Software
• Nonprofit Organizations
• Government and Municipal Entities

• Fellow, American College of Trial Lawyers

• Adjunct Settlement Judge, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Oklahoma, 2010–Present

• Member, Criminal Justice Act Panel, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Oklahoma, 2003–Present

• CJA Panel Representative, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Oklahoma, 2012–2016

• Frederic Dorwart, Lawyers PLLC, 1996–Present, Managing Member

• Litigation practice in New Mexico prior to joining the firm.

• Extensive trial and appellate experience in state and federal courts nationwide.

• FINRA arbitration and international arbitration experience, including proceedings before the London Court of International Arbitration.

University of New Mexico School of Law, J.D., 1993, magna cum laude

• Class Rank: 2 of 110

• Notes Editor, UNM Law Review

• Order of the Coif

• Recipient, Julia Raymond McCulloch Constitutional Law Award

Princeton University, B.A., United States History, 1987

• Varsity Football

Admissions

• Oklahoma, 1997

• New Mexico, 1993

• Colorado, 2020

• President, Board of Directors, H.O.W. Foundation Recovery Center of Oklahoma, LLC

• American College of Trial Lawyers, Fellow

• American Bar Association

• Tulsa County Bar Association, Litigation Section

• American Association of Trial Lawyers

• National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers

• Council Oak / Johnson-Sontag Inns of Court